Short answer: Compare on facts from primary sources, not on marketing claims. The key dimensions are accreditor identity and status, pathway eligibility (WFME/ECFMG fit), real COA, and clinical training geography. This registry's Compare tool surfaces accreditation, tuition, and Title IV side-by-side.
Last reviewed: 2026-11-02.
Why "best school" rankings mislead
Caribbean medical school rankings typically reflect:
- Affiliations (paid or unpaid relationships)
- Marketing budgets — which school can promote itself most aggressively
- Outdated or undated data — accreditation statuses and costs change
Rankings rarely disclose methodology, don't reveal who is in the denominator for Match statistics, and don't distinguish between different accreditors. This registry is not a ranking — it is a registry.
Framework: what to compare
1. Accreditor identity and exact status
Not all accreditors are equivalent. Compare:
| Dimension | What to check | |---|---| | Which body? | CAAM-HP, ACCM, NVAO, GMDC, IAAR, other | | WFME-recognized? | WFME Recognition Status | | Exact status | Accredited / with conditions / provisional / withdrawn | | Term | When does the current accreditation period end? | | Source date | When did you check? Agency lists change |
Use the accreditation registry for side-by-side rows, or compare two schools directly.
2. Pathway eligibility for your target
Different accreditors have different implications for:
- ECFMG certification eligibility — check your graduation year
- WDOMS sponsor notes — affects exam eligibility
- State medical licensing board requirements — each state board may have different rules
- U.S. Title IV federal loan availability
3. Total cost of attendance
Do not compare tuition alone. Compare:
- Tuition (basic sciences) × number of semesters
- Tuition (clinical years) × number of semesters — often a different rate
- Mandatory fees (technology, insurance, lab)
- Living costs: island campus vs U.S. clinical city
- Travel between campuses and home
- USMLE, NBME, and application fees
Use the cost calculator as a worksheet, and see the cost guide. This registry only publishes tuition figures with a dated primary source.
4. Clinical training geography and quality
- Where exactly do core clerkships take place (which states, which hospitals)?
- Are the clinical sites currently affiliated (not from a 3-year-old brochure)?
- Which states have approved the program's clinical affiliations?
- What proportion of students train in U.S.-accredited hospitals?
5. Outcomes (with methodology)
- Match rate: who is in the denominator? Active candidates only? All graduates?
- USMLE Step 1 / Step 2 CK pass rates: first attempt or including retakes?
- Which years? Recent cohorts may differ from historical data
Demand the definition before trusting any percentage.
Using the Compare tool
Our Compare tool puts up to four schools side-by-side with:
- Accreditation chips (body + exact status)
- Tuition (registry figure from primary schedule where available)
- Title IV eligibility
- Clinical countries
- Last verified date
- Source links
Pre-loaded Big-4 pairs:
What to do after comparing
- Short-list 2–3 schools that meet your accreditor and pathway requirements
- Open each school's profile and click through to every source link
- Re-verify the agency list yourself — it may have updated since our last check
- Contact each school's admissions office with specific questions about clinical sites and MCAT/GPA
- Consult an independent medical education advisor (not affiliated with a school)
Primary sources for comparison research
- CAAM-HP assessed programs
- ACCM assessed programmes
- NVAO public decisions
- WFME Recognition Status
- ECFMG eligibility documentation
- U.S. Department of Education foreign schools
- WDOMS school listing
See also
- Are Caribbean medical schools accredited?
- What does "accredited with conditions" mean?
- ECFMG and the U.S. pathway
- Cost of Caribbean medical school
- How to evaluate a Caribbean medical school
- Compare tool
- Accreditation registry